Sunday, July 14, 2013

The Most Reverend Bishop Athanasius Schneider - "Vatican II Must be Clar...


  1. Excellent interview by Mike Voris.
    However, he failed to develop the fact
    that the lack of clarity & precision in
    the liturgical texts was due precisely to the abandoning
    of scholastic language & that of St Thomas Aquinas
    in favor of one which is called pastoral; it is very
    illusive, flowering, and as diffult to pin down as trying
    to nail jello to the wall.

    Anothr omission during Mr Voris' interview is that he overlooked the failure of the Council to publicly condemn international Communism.

    If the Council were truly pastoral as it claimed to be, wouldn't you think that Vatican II would have condemned it since countless numbers suffered at it hands?

  2. your comments are very good; I only would say that the interview really focused on the three documents that are crucial for clarification and correction by the Magisterium, i.e. the Pope; and these are precisely what the SSPX have been saying vehemently and are not being listened to. As far as the other items u mention, I do believe that should be in another interview. Bishop Schneider is very orthodox.